the series join us

Check out ExxonMobil Masterpiece Theatre's American Collection website at pbs.org for additional teacher information

Viewing Guide for The Song of the Lark
By Susan Thurman

Combining the viewing of a cinematic production with a reading of the actual text of a novel is an effective way to teach literature. In this era of high tech media and entertainment, students benefit greatly from being exposed to both representations of Willa Cather's story.  

Below is a resource guide to help your class get the most from viewing and or reading Willa Cather's The Song of the Lark.  The guide has been constructed to benefit students of all grades levels and abilities.  Whether your teaching interests lie in the Internet, film or close text reading, you may use these ideas to enhance your lessons of the novel.  The guide has been organized into the following sections: 

I.  Preparation, Comprehension and Analysis

II.  Supplemental Information

 

I.  Preparation, Comprehension and Analysis

     Pre-Viewing/Reading Discussion Questions

    Below is a list of twenty discussion questions for you to pose to your students before viewing the film or reading the book.  These questions serve to stimulate students' thinking about the various themes in The Song of the Lark.

    1)  What minimum age should a young woman be before her parents allow her to leave school and go to work?

    2)  At what age should a young woman be allowed to leave home and go to another city to live?

    3)  Is there anyone who has a special nickname for you, one that others do not use?  Do you like this person's using the nickname?  Is there a particular reason why this person uses the nickname?

    4)  Thea, the heroine of the story, has several mentors while she is growing up.  Name some people whom you consider to be your mentors.  What makes these particular people unique to you?

    5)  Thea, the heroine, is eleven in the beginning of the story, yet the man who wants to marry her when she grows up is in his thirties.  Do you consider it to be in bad taste for a man in his thirties to have his eyes already set for someone that young?  Fill in the blank: For a man in his thirties, a young lady would need to be at least __________ years old before he should have any "designs" on her future with him.

    6)  If you were told you had talent in a certain area, how many hours a day would you be willing to devote to advancing your talent?  Suppose you knew you had the capacity to be the best in town in your field. Would you then increase your devotion?  What if you could be the best in the state? in the country?

    7)  Where do you go when you need to be alone?  What special qualities does this place hold for you?

    8)  If you left home for a year, whom — besides your family — would you be homesick for?

    9)  If you left home for a year, what — besides your family's residence — would you be homesick for?

    10)  Where can you go to feel close to nature?  At what particular times do you go there?

    11)  How do you feel when family members brag about your achievements?  Does it make you feel even prouder or does it embarrass you?  Why?

    12)  At this point in your life, do you think you would be happier living in a place of quite a different size from where you now live?  (For example, if you live in a big city, would you be happier in a small town or in the country?  If you live in a small town or in the country, would you be happier in a big city?)  Why?

    13)  What would you do if you found out that someone you care about were keeping a secret from you, a secret that would alter your relationship with that person?  Would you confront the person or would you let the situation play itself out?

    14)  Do you feel that the area where you live has a social hierarchy?  That is, do some people believe that they are better than others?  If so, what do you think makes them feel so superior?  Do you think that those they look down on realize that they're looked down on?  Are there different areas of town where the various social strata live?

    15)  If you're at a party, what type of music do you like to listen to?  What other types of music do you enjoy?  Are there particular times when one type of music suits you better than others?

    16)  If you were going somewhere abroad to live for a while, what mementos would you take to remind you of home, family or friends?  (Remember that you have to pack all of them — as well as your clothes and other personal items — in one trunk.)

    17)  Thea, the main character in the movie and novel, says, "…I'd like to have somebody human to make a report to once in a while."  To whom do you "make a report"? In other words, to what friends or family do you tell your day-to-day activities?  How important is this to you?

    18)  What do you think is the secret for a truly successful person?  Does talent alone seem to be enough to make someone a success?  If not, what else is needed?

    19)  One of the characters in the movie is described as being "good at heart" but having "no head."  Do you know anyone who is like this — kind, but without common sense?

    20)  At this stage in your life, do you feel you listen to your own heart or do you generally do what's expected of you?  How has this changed in the last five years?

      Post-Viewing/Reading Assignment Ideas

    Below are thirty-nine thought provoking ideas for writing and or research about The Song of the Lark.  Assignments built around these ideas require students to (1) conduct research through library and Internet resources; (2) think in a multidisciplinary fashion; and (3) make creative leaps in their analysis and interpretation of the novel.

    1)  The title of the book and the film is taken from a painting by the French painter Jules Breton (1827-1906). Thea visited the Art Institute of Chicago to view the painting, and you can see it at this homepage: http://www.powerlines.com/personal/lark.html.

    Thea found home in viewing the painting and in hearing Dvorak's Symphony in E Minor. Look through books of paintings and find a work of art with which you identify.  Give the title (remember to put a painting's title in italics), the painter and where the painting now can be found.  Also, be sure to explain what about this artwork makes you connect with it. Alternately, find a musical work with which you identify and tell what about it makes you "find home." (Remember that titles of long works are put in italics; titles of short works are enclosed in quotation marks.)

    2)  A number of geographic areas are mentioned in the book and film. Research any of the following places to determine current facts about them (population, type of government, employment data, historical change in the last one hundred years, etc.): Colorado, Chicago, New York City, Germany, Dresden (Germany), Mexico and Arizona.

    3)  Mining in Colorado played a role in the lives of two main characters of The Song of the Lark (Ray Kennedy and Dr. Archie).  Research Colorado silver mining in the late 1800s and report to the class.

    4)  Throughout most of the book, the main method of long-distance transportation was the railroad.  Examine the role the railroad played in the development of the country in the latter part of the 1800s.

    5)  At the end of the book and film, the automobile had come into existence. Take a look at the automobile in the early part of the 1900s and report on its growth as a popular vehicle for the masses.

    6)  The ancient homes of the Cliff Dwellers were particularly moving for Thea Kronborg. Investigate more about the Cliff Dwellers, their habitat, their ways of life, their time span and why they died out. One place on the Internet to find information is: http://www.mesaverde.org/mvnp/pages/cliffp1.html

    7)  The Art Institute of Chicago was important during Thea's time and it continues to be so today.  Research the Art Institute and report to the class about other important paintings and artwork which can be viewed there.  The Internet address is: http://www.artic.edu/aic/index.html.

    8)  Thea rose to sing some of the most difficult and demanding operatic roles, those by German composer Richard Wagner.  Research the life of this influential composer and report to the class.  If you can find parts of some of his famous pieces, bring in the music and let your classmates put the music with the man.  One site to find information about Wagner is at: http://www.geocities.com/Vienna/Strasse/8947/wagner.html.

    9)  Swedish-American opera mezzo-soprano Olive Fremstad was said to be the inspiration for Thea Kronborg.  Research this opera singer and report highlights of her career to the class.

    10)  Willa Cather's life is also paralleled in The Song of the Lark.  Research how the author reflected her own life in the book and movie.

    11)  Cather cut almost one-tenth of the novel for its 1932 reissue.  Read the revised novel and write a compare/contrast paper, or give a book review in which you write why one version is better than the other.

    12)  Ray Kennedy left Thea $600 in insurance.  Since the book was set in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, research how much $600 would be in modern terms.

    13)  In the end of the book and film, mention is made of the Dresden Opera House.  You can view the current building at this site:  http://www.semperoper.de/Semper_eng/index.html

    The facility in Dresden was built in 1838-41 and has been restored twice.  The first restoration came as a result of a fire in 1860.  Research why the second restoration was necessary.  ( Teacher's Note: The answer is that the building was destroyed by Allied firebombing in February 1945. The restoration was completed in 1985.)

    14)  Thea's triumphal performance at the New York City Metropolitan Opera House shows that she has finally achieved what she yearned for.  History about the opera house in the late 1800s and early 1900s can be found at:  http://www.metopera.org/history/week-961021.html.

    Study the former opera house and then compare it to the present New York City Metropolitan Opera House in Lincoln Center.  Try this homepage for interesting information: http://www.metopera.org/history/week-960916.html .

    15)  Pretend you are a news reporter for the Moonstone paper.  Write an article telling about the "hometown girl" who became a star.

    16)  As a news reporter for the Moonstone paper, write an article about Ray Kennedy's death.

    17)  Pretend you are Aunt Tilly. Write a letter to Thea, telling about your life in Moonstone and how you keep up with Thea's career — and how you make sure the other Moonstone residents are aware of her career as well.

    18)  There are a number of differences in fashion in between the time in which the book and film are set and the present day.  Research what was fashionable in Thea's day.  If you have access to vintage clothing, see if you can wear an outfit that fits Thea's time period.

    19)  Fred Ottenburg tells Thea that he brought a half dozen Worth gowns through customs for Mrs. Nathanmeyer.  Research the Worth name in fashion and report to the class.  Some information can be found at:  http://carolsutton.net/worth_source_story.html

    20)  Take a look at old newspapers from end of the1800s and the beginning of the 1900s and see what was happening in your town at that time.  What were some of the news items?  What were types of stores that are no longer in existence?  Are any stores that advertised then still in existence?  How would you characterize the style of writing in the old papers?  Is it easier or more difficult to read?

    21)  At one point early in the book and film, Mrs. Kohler was cooking hasenpfeffer, a traditional German dish.  If you are interested in the culinary arts, find a recipe for this dish. It's even better if you make it and bring it in for the class to sample.  A few sources for the recipe can be found at these sites:

    22)  Ray Kennedy talks about looting the aboriginal burial mounds, a subject that has recently been in the news.  Research the current laws and standards about such a deed.

    23)  Mention is made of the famous Tabor Opera House in Colorado.  Research why this structure is so renowned.  Some information can be found at:

    24)  The Brown Palace Hotel is still one of the best places to stay when in Denver. Find information about it and share your discoveries with the class. Among other places, you can look at:

    25)  Both Dr. Archie and Fred Ottenburg suffered from very unhappy marriages.  Write a paper comparing and contrasting the two marriages and the way the husbands and wives conducted themselves.

    26)  At the end of the book and film, Tilly reads in the New York paper about Thea's having sung for the king at Buckingham Palace.  This would have been King Edward VII.  Research this king and his Buckingham Palace residence.

    27)  The Waldorf in New York City mentioned in the book and movie has moved to a new location.  The Waldorf that Thea knew was razed to make way for another famous building.  Research and find out what famous building now sits on the site of the former Waldorf.  Try this site for the information:  http://www.thecityreview.com/waldorf.html

    (Teacher's note: The old Waldorf-Astoria was razed in 1930 for construction of the Empire State Building. For an interesting sidebar about a Waldorf employee during Thea's time period, see this site:  http://www.1000islands.com/castle/oscarotw.htm .)

    28)  Mention is made of Thea's and Fred's friend Landry singing at Weber and Fields.  Weber and Fields were two halves of a vaudeville act who later went on to other business enterprises, including owning their own Broadway theater — the 665-seat Weber & Fields Music Hall.  Find more information about this famous duo.  One source can be found at: http://calliope.jhu.edu/demo/reviews_in_american_history/23.4glenn.html

    29)  The famous Carnegie Hall was the site of a concert by Harsanyi.  Research Carnegie Hall then and now.  One place to find information is located at this site: http://www.carnegiehall.org/visit/timeline/index.html  

    30)  Tilly was also proud of Thea's "successes at Covent Garden." You can read about the Royal Opera House in Covent Garden at http://www.fsz.bme.hu/opera/roh_history.html and then report to the class about this famous building.  

    31) Many hymns, songs and arias from operas and other works are noted in the book and the movie. Gather information about any of the following, including — if possible — their recordings to play for the rest of the class:

    • "Come, ye Disconsolate"
    • "La Golandrina"
    • "Ultimo Amor"
    • "Beloved, it is Night"
    • "Thy Sentinel Am I"  
    • "Rock of Ages"
    • "The Ninety and Nine"     
    • "Die Lorelei"     
    • "Rosa de Noche"    
    • "When Shepherds Watched" 
    • "El Parreño" 
    • "Marching Through Georgia"
    • "Tak for dit Räd"      
    • "O, Promise Me"    
    • "On Mighty Pens"
    • "Rejoice Greatly" 
    • "The Messiah"      
    • "I Know my Redeemer Liveth"
    • "Flow Gently, Sweet Afton" 
    • "Ave Maria" 
    • "Just Before the Battle, Mother" (from The Drummer Boy of Shiloh)

    32) Many famous singers, operas or composers are mentioned in the novel. Find and share information about any of these works or their creators:

    Operas:  Tannhäuser, Lohengrin, Die Walküre, Ring of the Niebelungs (Der Ring des Nibelungen), Il Trovatore, Das Rheingold, Die Walküre, Götterdämmerung Orpheus und Eurydice, La Gioconda

    Composers and Singers: Carl Czerny, Ludwig van Beethoven, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Frédéric François Chopin, Johann Sebastian Bach, Robert Alexander Schumann, Christoph Willibald Gluck, Johann Nepomuk Hummel,   Jenny Lind, Charles François Gounod, Edvard Grieg, Gustav Mahler, Antonin  Dvorak

    A guide to many great classical composers and pieces (including when and why they were written, where the pieces have been heard recently — movies, television, advertisements, etc.— and explanations of the pieces) can be found here: http://www.futurenet.co.uk/classicalnet/reference/reference.html

    33) Thea found home in the painting The Song of the Lark and in hearing Dvorak's Symphony in E Minor.  Are there any artistic or musical works which you find you identify with?  What are they and why?

    34)  Fred says to Dr. Archie, "[Thea] did the right thing there [by not coming home for her mother's funeral]." Do you agree or disagree?  Be sure to give reasons for your opinion.

    35)  Read Cather's short story A Wagner Matinee and write an essay comparing and contrasting it to The Song of the Lark.

    36)  Design a poster advertising an appearance by Thea Kronborg, using any of her performances.  Or design a poster for the Carnegie Hall performance of Andor Harsanyi.

    37)  Draw or sculpt a water vessel that could have been used by the females of the Ancient People. If you are sculpting the vessel, remember that no wheel was used by the Ancient People, so you may not use one either.

    38)  Create a travel brochure advertising a trip to visit the land of the Cliff Dwellers.  Be sure to emphasize what can be seen, the marvels of the history behind the honeycombed cities, accommodations for the guests, and any ecological points your "travel company" wants to stress.

    39)  Read Robert Frost's famous poem "The Road Less Traveled." Then think about all the times Thea decided upon the road less traveled.  Did her decisions, in fact, "make all the difference"?  How?  What would Thea's life have been like, had she not taken the roads she chose?

    What about in your own life -- have there been times that you have taken a less traveled road?  Do you now feel that your decision were wise ones?  Why or why not?

     Quotes to Write About

    Willa Cather's writings are full of interesting quotations. Read the following and then defend or refute the statement. (Note that you are not writing about the situation in the book, but rather about whether or not the quotation is true for life as you see it.)

    About public speaking, Gunner says, "…they oughtn't to make boys speak. It's all right for girls. They like to show off."

    When talking about reading a history of Paris, Dr. Archie says, "People are pretty much the same everywhere."

    When Thea is telling Wunsch that she couldn't learn German at school because it wasn't taught there, Wunsch replies, "It is always possible to learn when one likes."

    "The fear of the tongue, that terror of little towns, is usually felt more keenly by the minister's family than by other households."

    Dr. Archie says, "[The failures] don't leave any lasting scar in the world, and they don't affect the future. The things that last are the good things. The people who forge ahead and do something, they really count."

    Bowers says to Thea, "When you come to marketing your wares in the world, a little smoothness goes farther than a great deal of talent sometimes."

    Mrs. Harsanyi says to Thea, "You must not begin to fret about the successes of cheap people."

    Fred says to Thea, "A voice is not an instrument that's found ready-made. A voice is personality. It can be as big as a circus and as common as dirt."

    Fred says to Thea, "Don't you know that most of the people in the world are not individuals at all? They never have an individual idea or experience."

    Fred says to Dr. Archie, "…life is not quite so personal here [in New York City] as it is in your part of the world. People are more taken up by hobbies, interests that are less subject to reverses than their personal affairs."

    Thea says to Fred, "Sometimes I think that to be really honest, you must have been so poor that you've been tempted to steal."  

    Dr. Archie says to Fred, "…a man's not effective in politics unless he wants something for himself, and wants it hard.""

    Mrs. Kronborg says to Dr. Archie, "You have to keep your own counsel."

    In speaking to Thea about Fred's wife, Dr. Archie says, "It's a damned shame that a man should be tied up as [Fred] is, wasting all the best years of his life. A woman with general paresis ought to be legally dead."

    In saying that she doesn't have any personal life, Thea says to Dr. Archie, "Your work becomes your personal life. You are not much good until it does."

    Harsanyi says to his wife that Thea's secret is "every artist's secret" and that is "passion."

II.  Supplemental Information

     Major Characters

    A major work such as The Song of the Lark contains a multitude of characters that can often confuse readers.  Here's a "cheat list" of the major characters to help students focus their comprehension of the novel:

       Ray Kennedy — a railroad man who is in love with the much-younger Thea
       Thea Kronborg — a young singer, daughter of Swedish Methodist pastor
       Rev. and Mrs. Kronborg — Thea's parents
       Tilly Kronborg — Thea's aunt
       Dr. Howard Archie — Thea's friend and adviser
       Mrs. Archie — the doctor's wife; a mean-spirited woman
       Professor Wunsch — Thea's music teacher in Moonstone, a drunkard
       Fritz Kohler — a German tailor in Moonstone
       Spanish Johnny — a resident of Moonstone
       Andor Harsanyi — a concert pianist; one of Thea's teachers
       Frederick Ottenburg — a wealthy art patron and an amateur musician
       Madison Bowers — Thea's voice teacher in Chicago

     Maps

    Because The Song of the Lark spans many cities, countries and oceans, it may be helpful to  incorporate maps of the following places into your lessons:

     Domestic: Arizona  Chicago Colorado New York City

     Foreign: Germany Mexico

     Cinematic Techniques

    (under development)

     Literary Devices:

    Below are examples that illustrate Willa Cather's use of literary devices in The Song of the Lark.

    Foreshadowing

    Thea says, "Brothers are better."

    (from the narrative) "Wunsch and old Fritz and Spanish Johnny celebrated Christmas together, so joyously that Wunsch was unable to give Thea her lesson the next day."

    Thea says, "I'd like to go to Germany to study, some day."

    Upon seeing Thea, Wunsch thinks, "…Ah, she will run a long way; they cannot stop her."

    Speaking to Thea about Mrs. Kohler, Ray says, "…I hear the old woman goes to church every Sunday to hear you sing."

    (from the narrative) "The one complaint Ray's brakemen had to make of him was that he was too fussy about his caboose."

    (from the narrative)  "[Dr. Archie] had put all his money into mines above Colorado Springs, and he hoped for great returns from them."

    (from the narrative) "Thea was surprised that she did not feel a deeper sense of loss at leaving her old life behind her."

    Dr. Archie says, "I'm still chasing the elusive metal, Thea…I'm up to my neck in mines, and I'm going to be a rich man some day."

    Simile 

    Wunsch thinks of Thea: " …she was like the yellow prickly-pear blossoms that open there in the desert; thornier and sturdier than the maiden flowers he remembered; not so sweet, but wonderful."

     Euphemism  

    Mr. Larson says, "My soprano is a young married woman and is temporarily indisposed."

     Personification  

    (from the narrative) "The rich, noisy city, fat with food and drink, is a spent thing; its chief concern is its digestion and its little game of hide-and-seek with the undertaker.

    Metaphor  

    Fred says to Dr. Archie, "A man is an owl to live in such a place alone, Archie." 

     Vocabulary List: (Taken from dialogue)

    Here is a list of terms that students may have particular difficulty in understanding as they read the novel:

    A - L

    • aborigines = native people
    • alto = the second highest singing voice
    • anaesthetized = without awareness or sensitivity
    • airs= melodies, tunes
    • aria = an elaborate melody sung by a single voice
    • barbarous = cruel, inhuman
    • brava = a shout of approval used for a female
    • cantankerous = irritable, surly
    • conscientious = devoted, principled
    • contralto = a singing voice between a tenor and a mezzo-soprano
    • cosmopolitan = someone sophisticated and worldly
    • crescendo = musically, an increase in volume
    • defer = yield, submit
    • diction = pronunciation, enunciation, phraseology 
    • erysipelas = an acute feverish disease
    • forging (metals) = forming by heating and hammering
    • Frau = German for Mrs.
    • galop = music of a lively type of dance
    • green = unworldly, naïve
    • grub-stake = money or supplies given to a prospector on a promise of a share of the recovery  
    • guying = making fun of
    • impertinent = rude, insolent, disrespectful
    • inevitable= bound to happen
    • inimitable = unique, unequaled
    • keen = eager
    • kudos = praise

    M - Z

    • morphia = morphine
    • obstreperous =  noisy, rambunctious
    • oratorio = a lengthy choral work, usually of a religious nature
    • paresis = insanity
    • phlegmatic = apathetic, lethargic
    • poultice = a medicinal spread for sores or other lesions
    • preceptor = teacher, tutor
    • reticent = shy, uncommunicative
    • revelry = partying, merrymaking
    • score = musical arrangement or composition
    • sonata = an instrumental musical composition typically of three or four movements in contrasting forms and keys
    • soprano = the highest singing voice
    • stays = a girdle
    • troche = a medical tablet or lozenge
    • troop = collection, crew
    • vagrancy = wandering
    • vernacular =language of the common people 
    • vestige = trace

Susan Thurman currently teaches at Henderson Community College in Henderson, Kentucky.  She has also created several viewing guides for other films.

Lesson Plan Format: Click here to see the format for submission of lessons.